Fascinating Ohio Spot Named ‘Best Small Town’ In The Entire State

Updated On: June 2, 2025

Fascinating Ohio Spot Named 'Best Small Town' In The Entire State

Put-in-Bay: Ohio’s Most Fascinating Small Town

Nestled on South Bass Island in Lake Erie, Put-in-Bay stands out as one of Ohio’s most captivating small towns-frequently named among the “best” and “coolest” in the state and the nation. With a population of just over 150, this tiny resort village punches far above its weight in history, natural beauty, and vibrant entertainment.

A Storied Past and Unique Island Setting

Put-in-Bay’s history is as rich as its scenery. The village’s name comes from 18th-century schooners that would “put in” on the bay to wait out storms, and its strategic location played a pivotal role in the War of 1812.

From this harbor, Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry launched his fleet to defeat the British in the Battle of Lake Erie-a victory commemorated by the imposing Perry’s Victory & International Peace Memorial, which towers above the island and offers sweeping views of both the U.S. and Canada.

Today, the island’s historical significance is woven into its identity, with museums, monuments, and walking tours that bring the past to life for visitors of all ages.

A Playground for All Ages

Put-in-Bay is often called the “Key West of the North” for its lively, laid-back island vibe. The village transforms each summer into a bustling hub for families, couples, and groups of friends. Accessible by ferry or small aircraft, the island is car-light-most visitors opt for golf carts, bikes, or the Put-in-Bay Tour Train to explore its charming streets and scenic parks.

Top Attractions and Activities

Perry’s Victory & International Peace Memorial: The 352-foot monument is both a historical site and the island’s best lookout, with panoramic vistas of Lake Erie.
South Bass Island State Park: Ideal for hiking, picnicking, and lakefront relaxation.
Perry’s Cave & Family Fun Center: Explore an underground limestone cave, pan for gemstones, and play mini-golf.
Heineman’s Winery & Crystal Cave: Tour the world’s largest geode and sample local wines.
The Butterfly House: A lush, tropical garden home to hundreds of butterflies.
Lake Erie Islands Historical Society Museum: Dive into the island’s fascinating past.
DeRivera Park: The heart of downtown, perfect for picnics and people-watching.

Outdoor Adventure and Water Fun

Lake Erie’s sparkling waters are central to the Put-in-Bay experience. Visitors can rent kayaks, jet skis, or paddleboards, embark on fishing charters, or simply relax on the shore. The island’s marinas and docks bustle with pleasure boats and the occasional historic steamship.

Lively Nightlife and Island Events

Put-in-Bay is renowned for its energetic nightlife. Legendary bars like The Roundhouse and Mr. Ed’s host live music, DJ parties, and the famous Whiskey Light Celebration, drawing visitors from across the Midwest. The island’s calendar is packed with festivals, including the annual Pyrate Fest, Jeep Invasion, and the Lake Erie Islands Historical Weekend.

Family-Friendly and Relaxed

Despite its reputation as a party hotspot, Put-in-Bay is equally welcoming to families and nature lovers. The Aquatic Center offers hands-on learning about Lake Erie’s ecosystem, while the Nature Preserve and State Park provide peaceful escapes for hiking and birdwatching.

Getting Around

With limited car access, most visitors rent golf carts or bicycles for a fun, flexible way to see the sights. Taxis and the tour train offer additional options for getting around the compact village.

Why Put-in-Bay Is Ohio’s Best Small Town

Put-in-Bay’s blend of historical significance, natural beauty, and festive spirit has earned it a place on numerous “best small towns” lists, including recognition from Esquire, Smithsonian, and PlanetWare. Its unique island setting, vibrant community, and wealth of attractions make it a standout destination for anyone seeking a memorable Ohio getaway.

Whether you’re drawn by its pivotal role in American history, the promise of summer adventure, or the allure of island relaxation, Put-in-Bay delivers an experience unlike any other small town in the Buckeye State.